The “value” of Defence Synergia for young people interested in safeguarding the nation and
wanting to understand the hard power complexities of security
Eleanor Shaw
An appreciation by Eleanor Shaw, a University of York undergraduate reading History and
Politics who has interests in European Security issues and international affairs.
For an interested young person, the world of defence and security can seem almost impenetrable, with shifting alliances, force structures, and procurement debates largely discussed in ways which assume years of experience. Yet it is becoming increasingly clear in modern Britain that the stakes could not be higher: safeguarding the nation depends on decisions that blend diplomacy with hard power. This is where I believe an independent think-tank such as Defence Synergia provides a vital service, in that it helps make sense of the complexities of the defence of the realm through accessible analysis, and is open to addressing the many questions posed by young people entering the field such as myself.
Many may be inclined to question why the younger generation should concern themselves with defence. After all, isn’t this the preserve of our politicians, generals, and the many civil servants employed in the Ministry of Defence? The answer is becoming ever more clear: national security affects every citizen. Whether it be the overseas deployment of
our armed forces, the investment choices behind our deterrent, or persistent cyber threats, defence decisions markedly impact the world in which we live.
As such, a thorough understanding of Britain’s hard power ability and strategy, of its alliances and of how its security can be successfully balanced with other national needs, is essential. Moreover, with increasing numbers of individuals entering the field through the avenue of public service or academia (a group to which I admittedly belong) as opposed to traditional active military service, engaging with veterans who possess hands-on experience is indispensable.
Defence Synergia is an organisation I believe successfully bridges the gap between defence practitioners and the wider public. For a young person beginning to explore defence-related issues, in a sphere dominated by bias and partisanship, Defence Synergia’s apolitical nature and independence is crucial. The organisation publishes reports and
critiques on key publishings in the field of defence, such as the UK's Defence Strategy, which is how I came to know DS, engaging with subjects many young people would not know where to begin analysing.
Perhaps most importantly, Defence Synergia opens a space for discussion, much needed in an industry so constrained by secrecy and vagueness. It allows a rare opportunity for young people developing an interest in defence such as myself to gain not just information, but to begin building a framework for thinking strategically, with the help of
defence experts eager to pass on their knowledge and experience. As a result of my interactions with the organisation and its members, I believe Defence Synergia is able to provide the tools to help one understand more broadly why decisions are made, what options exist, and what the consequences may be for Britain and the wider world. For instance: discussions with members of Defence Synergia have encouraged me to think more critically about the future of defence strategy. I feel I have an increased appreciation for the importance and the reality of alliances, as well as the way strategy must adapt to shifting threats.
Ultimately, DS highlights the fact that safeguarding the nation is not only the task of those in uniform or government office; it requires informed citizens – specifically young citizens – who can contribute intelligently to public debate.